Review of Elizabeth Abbot, Haiti: The Duvaliers and their Legacy By Bob Corbett, 1989
read, and I try to lay out Abbott's argument in a clearer fashion than she does in the book.read, and I try to lay out Abbott's
argument in a clearer fashion than she does in the book.
read, and I try to lay out Abbott's argument in a clearer fashion than she does in the book.read, and I try to lay out Abbott's
argument in a clearer fashion than she does in the book.
This analysis of the economy of misery is Abbott's the most original and persuasive thesis. But Abbott enjoys the horror tales of
Duvalier terror, and there are millions of them. However, it is impossible to separate documented factual cases, or immediate
direct interviews with the subjects, from second, third or fourth hands tales and classic myths and gossip. Abbott tends to recite
them all as fact.
Regardless of Abbott's tendency to revel in the gossip, she has produced a provocative, informative book. All students and
friends of Haiti should read it to help them understand the shaping force that Duvalierism was and is on Haitian society. The
Misery is still the central fact of the Haitian economy. Foreign political policy makers and private donors alike must take this into
consideration in considering how to deal with Haiti. In recent years private voluntary agencies have managed to distance
themselves from the Haitian government and funds donated to such agencies do the little development and relief work which
gets done in Haiti. But Haitian governments are all to be suspected. The Duvalierist tradition of The Misery--in the interest of the
rich, is still the dominant policy of Duvalierist politics.
Duvalier terror, and there are millions of them. However, it is impossible to separate documented factual cases, or immediate
direct interviews with the subjects, from second, third or fourth hands tales and classic myths and gossip. Abbott tends to recite
them all as fact.
Regardless of Abbott's tendency to revel in the gossip, she has produced a provocative, informative book. All students and
friends of Haiti should read it to help them understand the shaping force that Duvalierism was and is on Haitian society. The
Misery is still the central fact of the Haitian economy. Foreign political policy makers and private donors alike must take this into
consideration in considering how to deal with Haiti. In recent years private voluntary agencies have managed to distance
themselves from the Haitian government and funds donated to such agencies do the little development and relief work which
gets done in Haiti. But Haitian governments are all to be suspected. The Duvalierist tradition of The Misery--in the interest of the
rich, is still the dominant policy of Duvalierist politics.
Visit: htt://www.webster.edu/CorbetandHaiti To
finish reading the rest of this essay and many
more of Bob Corbet from Webster University>>>
finish reading the rest of this essay and many
more of Bob Corbet from Webster University>>>
Just three years ago the Duvalier dynasty ended. The general consensus is that while
Haiti no longer has the Duvaliers, Duvalierism dominates Haiti. There is much to
support this claim. Not only is President General Avril, like his predecessor General
Namphy, one who worked himself up through the Duvalier system, but Duvalierist
political terror continues in Haiti. In September, 1988 Namphy engineered a Tonton
Macoute attack on the church of St. John Bosco.
The world was shocked, even Haiti was shocked. This was too much even for Haiti
and the Namphy government quickly fell. But memories are short. Francois Duvalier
routinely had Catholic Churches attacked in the early 1960s during the phase of his
consolidation of power in which he took on and defeated the Catholic Church. Duvalier
was himself excommunicated, but eventually was not only reinstated by Pope Paul VI,
but given the right to name the Haitian hierarchy and to discipline the Church. Duvalier
even had Macoutes among the Catholic priests.
Haiti no longer has the Duvaliers, Duvalierism dominates Haiti. There is much to
support this claim. Not only is President General Avril, like his predecessor General
Namphy, one who worked himself up through the Duvalier system, but Duvalierist
political terror continues in Haiti. In September, 1988 Namphy engineered a Tonton
Macoute attack on the church of St. John Bosco.
The world was shocked, even Haiti was shocked. This was too much even for Haiti
and the Namphy government quickly fell. But memories are short. Francois Duvalier
routinely had Catholic Churches attacked in the early 1960s during the phase of his
consolidation of power in which he took on and defeated the Catholic Church. Duvalier
was himself excommunicated, but eventually was not only reinstated by Pope Paul VI,
but given the right to name the Haitian hierarchy and to discipline the Church. Duvalier
even had Macoutes among the Catholic priests.
However, Abbott makes clear that this economy of Haiti was not the
concern of the Duvaliers. They had a different economy, Le Misere --
the misery of Haiti herself. Haiti is the poorest country in the Western
hemisphere She was this before the Duvaliers, except that the gap
between Haiti and the other poor countries in the West grew under
the Duvaliers.
That very poverty was the key note of their private economy. Sell the
misery. Foreign governments, religious and humanitarian
organizations poured hundreds of millions of dollars into Haitian
development and relief in the Duvalier years. Foreign Aid became
the primary source of national income.
Little of this money ever filtered down to the projects for which it was
donated. The Duvaliers and those on whom they smiled, stole the
overwhelming bulk of this money. Thus, the economy that mattered
to the Duvaliers--the Duvalierist system which is still firmly in
place--the economy of Haiti's misery--boomed in relation to those
for whom it was intended to boom.
concern of the Duvaliers. They had a different economy, Le Misere --
the misery of Haiti herself. Haiti is the poorest country in the Western
hemisphere She was this before the Duvaliers, except that the gap
between Haiti and the other poor countries in the West grew under
the Duvaliers.
That very poverty was the key note of their private economy. Sell the
misery. Foreign governments, religious and humanitarian
organizations poured hundreds of millions of dollars into Haitian
development and relief in the Duvalier years. Foreign Aid became
the primary source of national income.
Little of this money ever filtered down to the projects for which it was
donated. The Duvaliers and those on whom they smiled, stole the
overwhelming bulk of this money. Thus, the economy that mattered
to the Duvaliers--the Duvalierist system which is still firmly in
place--the economy of Haiti's misery--boomed in relation to those
for whom it was intended to boom.
Elizabeth Abbott's book is an attempt to detail the origins of Duvalierism, and to follow its changes in the various periods of the
lives of the two Duvaliers. Finally, she explains how the system works today, and what the political infighting is all about.
It is an insider's book. Abbott is married to Joe Namphy, gregarious, fun-loving brother of ex-president General Henri Namphy.
Abbott had access to many people from Haiti's wealthier circles and important figures of the political world. She provides a
chilling account of the terror that is beyond the imagination of most people. Papa Doc was an active and willing participant in the
terror, watching his beloved Macoutes torture victims from behind peep holes in the wall, and running the whole show from his
voluntary imprisonment in the National Palace.
Jean-Claude tolerated the system, but was much less active in the day to day running of it, allowing subordinates to have
greater authority. But, the system of terror remained essentially the same under both despots.
Perhaps the most startling thesis that Abbott presents is the claim that the real economy of Haiti today and under the Duvaliers
is its poverty. Haiti's economy is generally regarded as an agricultural economy with a small but growing manufacturing sector.
This economy suffered drastically during the 29 year reign of the Duvaliers. Yet their wealth and the wealth of those whom they
chose to allow into their inner circle grew fantastically. How could this be? If one studies this standard economy of
lives of the two Duvaliers. Finally, she explains how the system works today, and what the political infighting is all about.
It is an insider's book. Abbott is married to Joe Namphy, gregarious, fun-loving brother of ex-president General Henri Namphy.
Abbott had access to many people from Haiti's wealthier circles and important figures of the political world. She provides a
chilling account of the terror that is beyond the imagination of most people. Papa Doc was an active and willing participant in the
terror, watching his beloved Macoutes torture victims from behind peep holes in the wall, and running the whole show from his
voluntary imprisonment in the National Palace.
Jean-Claude tolerated the system, but was much less active in the day to day running of it, allowing subordinates to have
greater authority. But, the system of terror remained essentially the same under both despots.
Perhaps the most startling thesis that Abbott presents is the claim that the real economy of Haiti today and under the Duvaliers
is its poverty. Haiti's economy is generally regarded as an agricultural economy with a small but growing manufacturing sector.
This economy suffered drastically during the 29 year reign of the Duvaliers. Yet their wealth and the wealth of those whom they
chose to allow into their inner circle grew fantastically. How could this be? If one studies this standard economy of
 | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  | |  |
Haiti.MarvelHaiti.Com > Visit it today and help us build the largest information center about Haiti!
Haiti's Contribution
Advertise with us Haitian Product Search Business Listings News Haiti Haitian Arts Real Estate Compas Music Videos Events
©2008 Marvel-Haiti, Inc. All Rights Reserved: About us Contact Feedback Site Map Suggest a Site